Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Nov 13
Indiana's Cignetti Blasts CFP Drop to No. 9 as Big Ten Coaches Cite SEC Bias
Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Nov 13

Indiana's Cignetti Blasts CFP Drop to No. 9 as Big Ten Coaches Cite SEC Bias

3 articles · Updated · The New York Times · Nov 13

Summary

  • Nine-place Indiana coach Curt Cignetti escalated his attack on the CFP rankings with an X post using crying and clown emojis after the 8-1 Hoosiers slid from No. 4 to No. 9 during a bye week.
  • Alabama's rise to No. 3 despite two losses appeared to be a target of the jab; chairman Hunter Yurachek defended the Crimson Tide's four quality wins after their 31-13 victory at LSU.
  • Big Ten frustration runs beyond Indiana: all four SEC teams at 6-3 made the latest Top 25, while only Oregon and Ohio State are ranked among the conference's five 6-3 teams.
  • Illinois coach Bret Bielema said his team would probably be top 15 in the SEC after beating Nebraska, and Iowa's Kirk Ferentz mocked ESPN's influence over a ranking show he says he will not watch.
  • The dispute adds to broader questions about whether the playoff committee is rewarding conference brand strength over on-field resumes as postseason positioning tightens.

Insights

How can non-SEC teams overcome the committee's subjective brand favoritism to secure fair placement in the expanded playoff era?
If data proves conference bias, will the CFP committee ever be forced to adopt objective computer models for playoff selection?
Does the human eye test capture crucial football nuances, or is it just a convenient excuse to protect profitable historic programs?