Paramount+ Releases 6-Part Treasure Island Adaptation With Superpowers

Q: With its premiere tomorrow, will David Oyelowo's brilliant performance save this heavily criticized, supernatural reimagining of Treasure Island from sinking?

Probably not on its own. Early reviews suggest David Oyelowo gives the series its strongest asset, but not enough to fully rescue a version of *Treasure Island* that many critics say is overwhelmed by reinvention. Across the coverage, Oyelowo’s Long John Silver is repeatedly singled out as magnetic and layered. Reviewers praise the way he brings menace, intelligence and emotional history to the role, with one calling him “particularly adept at doing a lot with a little.” Hayley Atwell has also drawn favorable notice, and the production itself is described as visually polished, with convincing ships, strong period settings and some tense action. The problem, according to critics, is broader than any one performance can fix. The six-part adaptation has been faulted for thin writing, repetitive plotting and a reliance on devices such as Jim Hawkins’ near-mystical memory, slow-motion combat and supernatural touches. Reviewers argue that these choices push the show away from Stevenson’s adventure spirit and weaken the central Jim-Silver dynamic that usually anchors the story. That leaves the series with a narrow path. Oyelowo may be enough to keep viewers curious, especially those open to a bold reinterpretation rather than a faithful adaptation. But if the criticism holds once audiences see it, his performance is more likely to be remembered as the best thing in a flawed production than the factor that keeps it afloat.

3 articles · Updated · The Guardian · Oct 12

A six-part US-UK "Treasure Island" series has debuted with a major rewrite of Robert Louis Stevenson’s novel, giving Jim Hawkins a quasi-mystical photographic memory and reshaping the adventure around that power.
That change drives the plot after Jim memorizes the treasure map before his mother Bess burns it, leaving Long John Silver hunting not a document but the boy’s recollection.
Hayley Atwell’s Bess is pushed to the foreground with added family drama and action, while David Oyelowo plays Silver in a production that also layers in slow-motion fights, spy-style scenes and a CGI parrot.
The release positions the 18th-century classic as another modern "reimagining," using fantasy elements and expanded backstories to refresh — and sharply alter — the original tale.

Sources

The Guardian11h ago

"Treasure Island" TV Adaptation Released, Features Superpowers

Forbes11h ago

Is 'Treasure Island' Worth Watching? The MGM Adaptation Is A Mixed Bag

kinoli.st23h ago

Treasure Island (2026) — Review, Cast, Episodes & Where to Watch

6 Sources

With its premiere tomorrow, will David Oyelowo's brilliant performance save this heavily criticized, supernatural reimagining of Treasure Island from sinking?

Why did creators replace the foundational mentor dynamic of a beloved 1883 pirate classic with slow-motion fights and a mystical memory gimmick?

Sources

6 total

The Guardian11h ago

"Treasure Island" TV Adaptation Released, Features Superpowers

Forbes11h ago

Is 'Treasure Island' Worth Watching? The MGM Adaptation Is A Mixed Bag

kinoli.st23h ago

Treasure Island (2026) — Review, Cast, Episodes & Where to Watch

Show all 6 sources

Paramount+ Releases 6-Part Treasure Island Adaptation With Superpowers

Summary

Sources

Insights

Sources