Yankees Commit 4 Errors in 5-2 ALDS Loss as Boone's McMahon Bet Backfires

Q: Will sloppy defense and a controversial catwalk rule seal the Yankees' playoff doom, or can they survive Game 3?

The Yankees are on the brink, but they are not finished yet; Game 3 is still winnable if they clean up the mistakes that put them here. Game 2 was less about bad luck than self-inflicted damage. New York’s defense unraveled early with multiple first-inning errors and catcher’s interference, and broader coverage says the Yankees finished with four errors plus the interference, leading to three unearned runs. In a short postseason series, that kind of sloppiness is usually fatal. The catwalk play was frustrating, but it was ruled correctly under Tropicana Field’s ground rules, so it is better understood as an odd break than the real reason they lost. The bigger concern is the offense. Through two ALDS games, the Yankees have managed only two total runs, both driven by Ben Rice, who homered twice in Game 2 and has been their only consistent threat. Cody Bellinger’s warning-track out with the bases loaded in the fifth was the missed chance that could have changed the night. Without Aaron Judge, the lineup has looked thin and too dependent on one bat. Still, New York has a path. Returning to Yankee Stadium helps, and Max Fried gives them a credible chance if he can work deep into the game. But Fried will need support against Nick Martinez and a Rays staff that has been one of the league’s deepest. If the Yankees defend cleanly and get production beyond Rice, they can force Game 4. If not, the sloppy defense from Game 2 will likely define their October.

Q: With Aaron Judge sidelined and offense stalling, can Ben Rice single-handedly save New York from a devastating ALDS sweep?

No. Ben Rice can keep the Yankees alive for a night, but he is very unlikely to rescue this series by himself. Rice has been New York’s only consistent threat. He hit both Yankees runs in Game 2 and has been their best postseason bat, carrying strong numbers against Tampa Bay, including a .356 average and seven regular-season homers against the Rays. With Aaron Judge sidelined, his importance is obvious. But the larger problem is that the Yankees’ collapse is not just about missing one star. Through two ALDS games, New York has scored only two runs total. In Game 2, they also handed Tampa Bay extra chances with four errors and catcher’s interference, leading to three unearned runs. Even a hot hitter cannot offset that kind of sloppiness. Tampa Bay also has a clear plan for Rice. The Rays have avoided giving him the four-seam fastballs he crushes, instead attacking with changeups, cutters and sinkers. That approach has limited him outside the two solo homers. Their pitching depth has backed it up, with Rasmussen, Peralta and a deep bullpen consistently shutting down the rest of the lineup. If the Yankees are going to avoid a sweep in the Bronx, Rice must stay hot, but he needs help immediately from Cody Bellinger, Jazz Chisholm Jr., Austin Wells and the rest of the order. They also need a clean start from Max Fried and much sharper defense. Rice can be the catalyst. He cannot be the entire solution.

3 articles · Updated · New York Post · Oct 6

Four Yankees errors fueled a 5-2 Game 2 loss to Tampa Bay, with three miscues in the first inning helping produce an unearned run and putting New York in a 2-0 ALDS hole.
Boone had kept Ryan McMahon at third base to "prioritize the defense," but McMahon misplayed Yandy Diaz's second-pitch grounder and later went 0-for-2 with a walk before being lifted for a pinch hitter.
Boone said he considered Anthony Volpe at third but did not want his second career start there on Tropicana Field's turf in a playoff game, while Jose Caballero stayed in a bench utility role before entering late defensively.
McMahon is 1-for-7 this postseason and had entered 1-for-14 career against Freddy Peralta; with right-hander Nick Martinez lined up for Game 3, Boone now faces another lineup call as New York returns home needing a win.