Former Chief Details 2009 Raymond Horsch Arrest as 7 Women Are Linked to Olney Home
Updated
Updated · WPVI-TV · Sep 17
Former Chief Details 2009 Raymond Horsch Arrest as 7 Women Are Linked to Olney Home
3 articles · Updated · WPVI-TV · Sep 17
Summary
Robert Scafidi said his 2009 arrest of Raymond Horsch in Chalfont turned up nearly 200 marijuana plants, firearms and several female IDs now drawing renewed scrutiny in the Philadelphia missing-women probe.
That account adds background to an investigation centered on Eugene Horsch's West Chew Avenue home in Olney, where police say seven women have been linked and five appeared injured, lifeless or possibly dead in recovered images and videos.
Amy McHale, 44, was last seen in 2016 and her family says she was last seen at the Olney house; she had previously been married to Raymond Horsch and was also remembered by Chalfont neighbors.
Philadelphia police said they have not searched the Chalfont property, even as current owners say a large safe built into the basement foundation from the Horsch era was sealed behind renovated walls.
June searches of the Olney home found fake law-enforcement credentials, drugs, a firearm, hundreds of thousands of photos and videos, and unidentified chemicals; police plan another warrant search later this month, with no bodies recovered or related charges filed.
What secrets lie within the excavated underground pipe and five mysterious urns found at the Philadelphia property linked to seven missing women?
How did a father and son amass a terrifying cache of women's IDs and digital evidence without police intervention for over a decade?
7 Missing Women, 1 Million Digital Files: The Horsch Family, the Olney House of Horrors, and the Unsolved Crimes of Philadelphia
Overview
The investigation into Eugene Horsch began with his arrest in June 2026, after police found weapons, drugs, and a fake DEA badge in his car. This led authorities to the Horsch family home in Olney, where they uncovered a chemical lab and a massive digital archive, but no physical remains or DNA evidence. Despite disturbing footage and writings linking the Horsch family to missing women, legal challenges remain because some women depicted as dead were later found alive, and no bodies have been recovered. As a result, Eugene Horsch faces only federal charges, while the full truth behind the disappearances remains unresolved.