Updated
Updated · The New Republic · Sep 8
Haaretz Says Netanyahu Ignored Sept. 15 Hamas Warning Before Oct. 7 Attack
Updated
Updated · The New Republic · Sep 8

Haaretz Says Netanyahu Ignored Sept. 15 Hamas Warning Before Oct. 7 Attack

3 articles · Updated · The New Republic · Sep 8

Summary

  • Sept. 15 intelligence warnings about a Hamas “earthquake” and “huge surprise” were relayed to Benjamin Netanyahu nearly two weeks before Oct. 7, but he did not brief the IDF, Mossad or other officials, Haaretz reported.
  • A defense ministry meeting on Sept. 17 produced no decisions, and a 45-minute call from UAE President Mohammed bin Zayed warning that “something there is about to explode” also failed to trigger action.
  • The report says Netanyahu had already scaled back prisoner releases and delayed an exchange committee, helping collapse talks with Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar in September and further destabilize the situation.
  • About 1,200 Israelis were killed in the Oct. 7 attack; a senior Shin Bet official said fuller awareness of the warnings might have changed Israel’s threat assessment.
  • Naftali Bennett called Netanyahu’s conduct “criminal negligence” and renewed demands for a state commission of inquiry, while Netanyahu’s office has denied he received any personal warning.

Insights

If allied leaders explicitly warned Netanyahu before October 7, why were Israel's top security chiefs kept completely in the dark?
How did profound confirmation bias cause a nation's leadership to ignore direct warnings from the UAE about a massive impending assault?
Will the revelation of a secret 45-minute warning call finally force a state commission of inquiry into the October 7 intelligence failures?