Updated
Updated · The Guardian · Aug 6
Raz Segal Wins $250,000 UMN Settlement Over Rescinded Job Offer
Updated
Updated · The Guardian · Aug 6

Raz Segal Wins $250,000 UMN Settlement Over Rescinded Job Offer

1 articles · Updated · The Guardian · Aug 6

Summary

  • $250,000 ended Raz Segal’s dispute with the University of Minnesota more than two years after it withdrew his offer to lead its Holocaust and Genocide Studies center; the deal does not admit wrongdoing.
  • Emails obtained by Segal showed UMN initially defended the June 2024 hire, then retreated after donor, activist and legislative pressure over his Gaza writings, including warnings that pledges and fundraising could be hit.
  • The university pulled the offer five days after making it, citing community "perspective," after critics accused Segal of justifying Hamas—an allegation he rejected, noting his op-ed also called the 7 October attacks mass murder and a war crime.
  • 40 Holocaust and genocide scholars, UMN faculty and the AAUP backed Segal, arguing the reversal violated academic freedom; faculty later passed a no-confidence vote against then-interim president Jeff Ettinger and the provost.
  • Segal, now at Stockton University, said the settlement should encourage other scholars punished over criticism of Israel to challenge universities, while the Minnesota post remains unfilled.

Insights

How does a withdrawn job offer over a controversial op-ed threaten the future of global genocide research?
Will a $250,000 payout stop universities from letting wealthy donors secretly control academic hiring decisions?
Can academic freedom survive when institutions prioritize donor demands over near-unanimous faculty hiring recommendations?