Updated
Updated · Fox News · Jun 23
DOJ Investigates Poetica Coffee Over Dan Goldman Ban and Refund as Israel Rift Roils Brooklyn
Updated
Updated · Fox News · Jun 23

DOJ Investigates Poetica Coffee Over Dan Goldman Ban and Refund as Israel Rift Roils Brooklyn

3 articles · Updated · Fox News · Jun 23

Summary

  • Harmeet Dhillon said the Justice Department opened a civil-rights investigation into Poetica Coffee over alleged "denial of service taunts" after the Brooklyn shop banned Rep. Dan Goldman and refunded his purchase.
  • Goldman told CNN the visit itself was friendly — including a kind barista and a large tip — and said the later Instagram post accusing him of backing "genocide" was the opposite of what happened in the store.
  • Poetica’s deleted post said staff would have turned Goldman away if they had recognized him, called him a "genocide enabler," and said his money was refunded because the shop does not serve people it labels racist or fascist.
  • Goldman, who is Jewish and describes himself as a liberal Zionist critical of Benjamin Netanyahu, said conflating American Jews with Israeli government actions is fueling rising antisemitism in the United States.
  • The dispute highlights a widening split on the Democratic left over Israel, with Goldman also facing a primary challenge from former New York City Comptroller Brad Lander, a sharp critic of Israel.

Insights

When a coffee shop denies service over politics, where does free speech end and a federal crime begin?
Can a customer's political support for a country be legally separated from their religious or ethnic identity?